Nussbaum is of the belief that, among other causal factors, a sense of connectivity and commonality is required between the victim and the onlooker for compassion to be aroused within the onlooker.
In another part of his speech, Wiesel says: While it may just be one group of people experiencing injustice at the hands of indifference at different points in time, it will always be out there as a threat to all of us until it is forever a thing of the past.
History has Human indifference essay its lesson and offered its testimony; the only question that remains is whether we will take heed. According to Nussbaum, if we are not concerned for the fate of suffering Rwandans, then they will simply continue to suffer; according to Robbins, if we do not respond to the plight of sweatshop laborers, then their plight will remain.
It is not, as Nussbaum and Robbins seem to imply, a simple lack of compassion or action to complement compassion, both of which lead to the same result; rather, it is a helping hand to the oppressor. Louis is a case in point. A lack of compassion will never lead to action, and compassion without action is of no help to the sufferer.
Essentially, his question raises two separate but equally important issues: Analyzing the prevailing approaches to these questions, from the perspective of two significantly different generations, ought to give deeper insight into the concept of indifference, how it might explain the global response to the Holocaust, and, perhaps more importantly, how it relates to the world today.
And if the international community was truly unaware of what was taking place a theory which has long since been abandonedwhy did the Europeans who were aware of but not subject to Nazi persecution sit back and watch?
They would have bombed the railways leading to Birkenau, just the railways, just once.
Wiesel used repetition in his speech in order to exaggerate the power that indifference has. Wiesel was raised in the small town of Sighet, where he spent most of his early life devoted to religion and contemplation. He uses ethos because, due to the fact that Roosevelt was former president, everyone in the United States knew and most looked up to him.
When giving his speech, Elie spoke about a young Jewish boy; another survivor, and how he felt after being freed. He spoke efficiently and allowed his speech to become one of the most successful and most popular speeches of all time. Wiesel, representing the approach to indifference of generations past that have learned from history and experience, could respond to this idea with several pieces of contradictory evidence.
Do we feel their pain, their agony? He uses this countless other times in the course of his speech due to the long and emotional journey that he had overcome.
Louis was a ship that requested refuge in the U. Oh, we see them on television, we read about them in the papers, and we do so with a broken heart. More essays like this: This sheds light upon a very relevant distinction between the notion of lack of compassion and the notion of indifference: Wiesel used both ethos and pathos when he brought up Franklin D.
The former effect is highlighted by the St. What motivates indifference, and what are its consequences? He starts off the speech with a statement that is similar to what you read if you were opening a storybook.
However, Wiesel later found out that the U.Elie Wiesel’s “The Perils of Indifference” Speech Elie Wiesel, a Noble Peace Prize winner and Boston University Professor, presented a speech as part of the Millennium Lecture Series at the White House on April 12, President Bill Clinton and his wife Hillary Clinton hosted the formal lecture series.
“Indifference, then, is not only a sin, it is a punishment.” (Wiesel,).In both cases it seems that people ignored the problems until it got to the point where it was almost too late a woman had to do something illegal at the time to make a point and millions had to die before something was done in Europe%(3).
Essay on Indifference to Child Abuse - While listening and reading “The Perils of Indifference” commentary by Elie Wiesel, I found the video and article very inspiring. The composition made me think about everyday issues we are indifferent to. Indifference, however, is an emotion in its own right; it is an inactively active response with real consequences that are rarely positive.
This important distinction captures within it a true understanding of the problem of indifference. "The Perils Of Indifference" Essays and Research Papers. The Perils Of Indifference Elizabeth Nordstrom Human Words | 3 Pages.
Open Document. A Complacent Society In Peril Essay A Complacent Society in Peril: The Current U.S.
Economic Dangers and Dismissive Americans. Indifference is not a beginning it is an end and it is always the friend to the enemy." Indifference means not different; a state in which is not at the border of evil or good, but in between cruelty and compassion.Download